Episode #615: Dementor Duck (POA Chapter 12, The Patronus)

Expecto Patronum! On this week’s episode of MuggleCast, Andrew, Micah, Laura and Chloé join Harry as he faces down his biggest fears under the tutelage of his greatest teacher! Plus, just what’s up with Oliver Wood? Was he really going to bench The Chosen One?

  • Happy 20th anniversary to Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix! On this week’s bonus MuggleCast on Patreon, we celebrate 20 years of the fifth book!
  • Chapter-by-Chapter continues with Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 12: The Patronus
  • Seven Word Summary: Lupin teaches Harry how to fight Dementors
  • How does the faculty feel about Lupin searching their personal spaces for a boggart?
  • Why is it that a boggart Dementor has the same effect on Harry as a real Dementor?
  • Harry struggles to find a powerful enough memory to conjure a Patronus. If we were in Harry’s position, what would we choose?
  • Harry’s internal struggle: for as much as he wants to fight the Dementor, he also wants to hear his parents
  • How much is the Horcrux influencing Harry at certain moments throughout this chapter?
  • Lupin is the first adult figure to really believe in Harry!
  • We examine Lupin’s reactions to the mentions of both James and Sirius
  • What if the dementor’s kiss was your FIRST (and only) kiss? ::vomit::
  • Lupin challenges Harry on Sirius receiving the Dementor’s Kiss. Is this as a friend, a compassionate human being or a bit of both?
  • Anywayyyyyyy, back to the Firebolt Fiasco!
  • Wouldn’t a teacher have found out eventually that Harry had a super cool new broom, and wonder where it came from? Which begs the question… shouldn’t there be standardized equipment for school-based Quidditch?
  • Did Oliver Wood plan to bench Harry? Is there nothing he wouldn’t do to win?
  • Odds & Ends cover Lupin’s condition, Neville’s password problem, Hermione’s favorite subject, and more!
  • Quizzitch: What does Percy win from his girlfriend Penelope when Gryffindor beats Ravenclaw?
  • Next Week: Chapter 13 of Prisoner of Azkaban, Gryffindor vs. Ravenclaw
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by Factor (visit FactorMeals.com/MuggleCast50 and use code mugglecast50 to get 50% off your first box)and BetterHelp (visit BetterHelp.com/MuggleCast today to get 10% off your first month).
  • Our Patreon is now offering 7-day free trials: Get full access to Bonus MuggleCasts and behind-the-scenes extras for a limited time!

Download now

Episode #614: The Real Housewives of Hogwarts (POA Chapter 11, The Firebolt)


On this week’s episode of MuggleCast, it’s Christmas break at Hogwarts and the castle is full of emotions… and mostly the not-so-good kind. Since Hogwarts doesn’t have a guidance counselor, we’ll be the trio’s guiding light today! Join Andrew, Eric, Micah, Laura and Jason as they enjoy a special meal inside The Great Hall with all the stress and awkwardness of a normal holiday family get-together!

  • Welcome Slug Club member, Jason!
  • Our Patreon is now offering 7-day free trials! Get full access to Bonus MuggleCasts and behind-the-scenes extras for a limited time!
  • Chapter-by-Chapter continues with Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 11: The Firebolt
  • Seven Word Summary: Somebody sends a Firebolt mysteriously to Harry
  • “A hatred such as he had never known before was coursing through Harry like poison.” Harry quickly grows obsessive over hating Sirius Black. How much could his Horcrux be fueling these emotions?
  • Why didn’t anyone ever tell Harry that the reason James and Lily Potter died was because their best friend Sirius had betrayed them?
  • We discuss how in both Prisoner of Azkaban and Order of the Phoenix, Harry not being given information negatively impacts his mental health and leads to reckless decision-making!
  • We analyze Harry’s treatment of Ron and Hermione in this  chapter
  • Comparing Gryffindors: Peter Pettigrew and Neville Longbottom
  • Comforting Hagrid: Lucius Malfoy’s influence rear its ugly head again! Did they not learn from the previous year when he threatened the Board of Governors?
  • Hagrid goes into grim detail about his time in Azkaban. Should Azkaban just be for maximum security prisoners?
  • Fan Fic Alert: “The Other Prisoner of Azkaban” by Jack Ichijouji
  • The Firebolt: Does Hogwarts not have a security measure in place for packages delivered to the school? Why, just now, are they “evaluating” the broom?
  • When 13 dine, the first to rise is the first to die: did Trelawney get it right after all?
  • What crawled up McGonagall’s @$$?
  • Hermione’s Most Gryffindor Moment
  • Odds & Ends cover Manticores, Lupin’s condition, Pettigrew’s finger and more!
  • Quizzitch: In which location does Harry’s first Patronus lesson take place?
  • Next Week: Chapter 12 of Prisoner of Azkaban, The Patronus
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now)  and ZocDoc (visit ZocDoc.com/MuggleCast, download the app, and schedule your next health appointment today)!

Download now

Episode #613: More Mead, More Secrets (POA Chapter 10, The Marauder’s Map)

From pranksters to marauders, this week’s chapter by chapter episode of MuggleCast is PACKED with all of our favorite characters and overflowing with plot. Join Andrew, Eric, Laura and Micah for a trip to Hogsmeade where we learn all about Sirius Black and his secret connection to Harry. Also, Professor Lupin reminds us why he’s our favorite teacher.

  • Our Patreon is now offering 7 day free trials! Get full access to Bonus MuggleCasts and behind the scenes extras for a limited time!
  • This week, we read through Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter 10, “The Marauder’s Map”!
  • Seven Word Summary: Secrets are divulged via Professors drinking Butterbeer
  • The hosts reflect on Harry’s attachment to his broken Nimbus 2000 and their own attachment to inanimate objects from their youth.
  • Harry’s isolation is hard to watch as with Book Five, but why doesn’t he reach out to Hermione and Ron? And, is Dumbledore to blame for all of it?
  • When Lupin reaches for Harry, should we have intuited more about his relationship to the boy? What about when he drops his briefcase?
  • Just how hard is it to learn the Patronus Charm and why isn’t it more widely taught?
  • Is the Marauder’s Map a dangerous magical item? Are Fred and George reckless for giving it to Harry?
  • How did Fred and George learn to use the map? Did the map itself help?
  • What impressive magic is involved in the function of the map?
  • Secrets are revealed and we wonder how the teachers could have kept this from Harry.
  • Quizzitch: What date is set for the Ministry hearing of Hagrid and Buckbeak?
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now) and BetterHelp (visit BetterHelp.com/MuggleCast today to get 10% off your first month).

Download now

MuggleMiniCast: Reviewing The Harry Potter Exhibition

This week, we’re taking a break from your regularly scheduled programming! BUT, Micah recently got a chance to preview Harry Potter: The Exhibition in New York City! Enjoy this MuggleMiniCast, which includes an interview with Tom Zaller, the President & CEO of Imagine Exhibitions.

  • Harry Potter: The Exhibition is now open in NYC’s Herald Square!
  • Micah speaks with Tom Zaller, the President & CEO of Imagine Exhibitions
  • Eric and Micah discuss how this exhibition differs from previous ones, what to expect as you make your way through, favorite moments, exclusive merchandise and more!
  • Next week: Chapter-by-Chapter returns with Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 10: The Marauder’s Map
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! Most recently we discussed if HBO Max should gear the new Harry Potter TV show towards adults and the next Wizarding World park coming to Universal Orlando! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast! As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #612: Bad Moon Rising (POA Chapter 9, Grim Defeat)

On this week’s episode, join us as we elude mass murderers with a sleepover in The Great Hall, attend a brutal Defense Against The Dark Arts class and play Quidditch in the worst possible conditions! What could possibly go wrong?

  • Harry Potter: The Exhibition is now open in NYC’s Herald Square! Micah got a chance to preview the experience, so keep an eye out for a Muggle MiniCast set to be released Memorial Day Weekend, which includes an interview with Tom Zaller, the President & CEO of Imagine Exhibitions.
  • Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 9: Grim Defeat
  • 7-Word Summary: Suspicions rock the Hogwarts student body tonight
  • With Sirius Black running around Hogwarts, shouldn’t at least one professor have stayed WITH the students in The Great Hall?
  • How did Sirius Black break into Hogwarts? Could Crookshanks have been involved? Has Sirius formed a connection with him at this point?
  • Why isn’t the Ministry alerted? This is now TWICE that Sirius has gotten past the Dementors!
  • What was the conversation like between Sirius Black and the Fat Lady?
  • We analyze Snape’s conduct in teaching Defense Against The Dark Arts, his great joy in criticizing the students’ lack of knowledge on the subject, and his attempt to sow seeds of doubt amongst about Lupin’s effectiveness as a teacher!
  • Snape is trying to OUT Lupin! Is Snape more vicious in Prisoner of Azkaban than he is at any other point in the series?
  • Do we think Sirius knows Lupin is at Hogwarts? Did he use Lupin’s “time of the month” to his advantage as well?
  • Could Lupin be “sick” because of the guilt of knowing that Sirius broke into the castle?
  • Quidditch Controversy: What’s up with the Slytherin favoritism?
  • Did the dementors come onto the Quidditch pitch because of Sirius?
  • Odds & Ends cover Cedric Diggory, Harry’s worst memory, Hermione’s bloodshot eyes and more!
  • Quizzitch: In what school year of theirs did the Weasley Twins obtain the Marauder’s map?
  • Next Week: Reminder, we’re off BUT you will get a very cool MuggleMiniCast all about the new Harry Potter: The Exhibition!
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by BetterHelp (visit BetterHelp.com/MuggleCast today to get 10% off your first month)!
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we’ll have a new look at the next Wizarding World park coming to Universal Orlando! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast! As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #611: Flight of the Friends (POA Chapter 8, Flight of the Fat Lady)

A Hogsmeade weekend approaches! Will Harry get his permission slip signed by a stand-in guardian in time? This week we are joined by Slug Club guest Ashley as we discuss Chapter 8 of Prisoner of Azkaban, Flight of the Fat Lady! We discuss Snape’s continued bad attitude, Lupin’s secret, and whether Harry could’ve gotten more out of him during their unplanned tea time. Enjoy!

  • Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 8: Flight of the Fat Lady
  • Welcome Slug Club guest Ashley! Host the show just like Ashley by joining us at Patreon.com/MuggleCast
  • 7-Word Summary, Justice for Micah Edition: Teachers forbid Harry from going to Hogsmeade
  • Snape picks on Neville worse than ever because he’s Snape. But does Trelawney pick on Harry due to her prophecy?
  • Did we ever have a teacher we were close with in the way that Parvati and Lavender are with Trelawney?
  • Is Oliver Wood justified in feeling desperate about this year’s Quidditch Cup?
  • Is McGonagall mean for not signing Harry’s permission slip? She knows about the Dursleys after all.
  • Hosts connect some great threads between Book 3 and Book 5.
  • Harry’s Hogsmeade FOMO hits us in the feels.
  • What makes Remus Lupin able and willing to say Voldemort’s name?
  • What If: Harry told Lupin about seeing the black dog off Privet Drive?
  • Is Hermione wrong to point out the evidence against Trelawney’s prediction about Binky? Could her doing so point to neurodivergent behavior?
  • Rename the Chapter returns! And hosts assign MVP of the Week.
  • Quzzitch: What does Hannah Abbott tell the students that Sirius Black can transform into?
  • Next week: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 9: Grim Defeat
  • This week’s show is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now) and HelloFresh (use code “muggle16” for 16 free meals at HelloFresh.com/Muggle16), and by ZocDoc. Visit Zocdoc dot com slash mugglecast, download the app, and schedule your next health appointment today.
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we discuss how the Harry Potter TV show could appeal more to adults! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast! As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #610: Severass Snape (POA Chapter 7, The Boggart in The Wardrobe)

Waddiwasi! On this week’s episode, grab your wand and get ready for the best magical classroom session to date …following the WORST magical classroom session to date! We compare and contrast Snape and Lupin’s teaching styles and the impact it has on the students of Hogwarts!

  • Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 7: The Boggart in The Wardrobe
  • 7-Word Summary: Neville fears rebuke when Snape “poisons” Trevor
  • We compare and contrast Harry’s worst class to date (Potions) with his best class to date (Defense Against The Dark Arts)
  • What do we make of Snape’s treatment of any student that is not in Slytherin?
  • We analyze the effects of bullying vs. collaboration in a classroom setting
  • What types of emotions does Snape elicit from Harry? Neville? Hermione?
  • Snape The Enabler creates an unsafe learning environment for his students
  • Micah plays devil’s advocate and rationalizes Snape’s actions toward both Neville (paying attention to detail) and Hermione (listening to the teacher)
  • What is the world is up with the Shrinking Solution?
  • Do Lupin and Peeves the Poltergeist share a history?
  • We contrast Snape’s treatment of Neville with Lupin’s desire to instill confidence in him (very reminiscent of how Harry works with Neville in Order of the Phoenix)
  • Does Lupin’s past with Snape inform his instruction to Neville about his Boggart?
  • Should Lupin have explained to Harry why he didn’t let him have a turn at the Boggart?
  • Connecting The Threads includes taking a look at the non-practical nature of Harry’s first class in Order of the Phoenix and a very important Boggart scene with Mrs. Weasley
  • Odds & Ends cover the origin of Boggarts, Draco’s knowledge of Sirius Black, Hermione’s secret, rat references and more!
  • Quzzitch: What is the name of the Fat Lady’s close friend?
  • Next week: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 8: Flight of The Fat Lady
  • This week’s show is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now) and HelloFresh (use code “muggle16” for 16 free meals at HelloFresh.com/Muggle16).
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we discuss how the Harry Potter TV show could appeal more to adults! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast! As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #609: Listeners React To The Harry Potter TV Show, and More MuggleMail

This week the hosts dive deep into the MuggleMail bag to bring listeners’ latest thoughts on recent Chapter-By-Chapter segments, as well as the new Harry Potter television series announcement! Voicemails include a 10 year old asking if Harry abuses Hedwig by making her travel so far, and someone has a theory about a Dementor that we all adopt on the spot as canon. Check out this laid back correspondence episode and be blown away by the opinions of our listeners.

  • Main Discussion: It’s a MuggleMail bag episode!
  • Voicemails ask if the WWOHP theme park will adjust itself to accommodate the new TV series, a potential Cursed Child adaptation featuring the original trio, and an HP cartoon.
  • More ideas for the HP TV series abound, with one listener asking how far the creators will stray from the look and feel of Hogwarts and surrounding areas.
  • Will members of the HP movies be brought into new roles as a nod to their original performances? Who do we think would be most likely?
  • One listener fan-casts the HP TV series for an actor from the Sandman series.
  • Could the TV show flesh out the moments when Hermione and Ron learned that they would be attending Hogwarts?
  • An eagle-eyed listener points out the use of the term ‘Azkaban guards’ disappears once we are introduced to Dementors.
  • We hear a tragic story of school bullying where the school covered it up, and comparisons are made to Hogwarts
  • The hosts reveal that double decker buses are not as prominent in the US as in the UK, in response to an email. And, the Sneakoscope was always right when Peter was around.
  • Our latest “Legacy” E-mail from 2006 asks us if we think Draco and Harry will work together to defeat Voldemort. We offer our theories 17 years too late.
  • Quizzitch: What animal causes the death of Lavender Brown’s rabbit?
  • Next Week: We return to Prisoner of Azkaban Chapter By Chapter with Chapter 7, “The Boggart in the Wardrobe”!!
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by BetterHelp (visit BetterHelp.com/MuggleCast today to get 10% off your first month), and also Indeed. Visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now.
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! Most recently, we discussed more breaking news… a brand-new Quidditch video game! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast!  As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #608: Is Trelawney Truthful or Trippin’? (POA Chapter 6, Talons and Tea Leaves)

On this week’s episode, get ready to broaden your minds and see past the mundane as we take our first Divination class! And remember to bow and blink while listening to this episode or your may be attacked by a hippogriff! 

  • News covers a new Quidditch video game is coming soon… for consoles! We’ll discuss it in this week’s Bonus MuggleCast, which is available exclusively on our Patreon!
  • Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 6: Talons and Tea Leaves
  • 7-Word Summary: McGonagall shades Trelawney during Transfiguration class, ooooooo!
  • We meet Professor Trelawney, who we later learn made the prophecy about Voldemort and Harry/Neville.
  • From Neville’s grandmother to Parvati’s stalker to an Easter departure, we keep track of Trelawney’s predictions and see if they come true!
  • Have any of the hosts ever seen a fortune teller or tarot card reader? What did we make of the experience?
  • Do we think Hermione is too quick to judge Trelawney? Does McGonagall influence her opinion?
  • Professor Hagrid… Micah argues Dumbledore set him up for failure from the start!
  • Name Origins: The Grim & Hippogriff
  • Does Harry offer to approach Buckbeak to test the validity of his death omen?
  • Odds & Ends cover paying attention in Transfiguration class (cough, animagi), Hermione’s busy class schedule, Sir Cadogan and more!
  • Quizzitch: What form does Parvati Patil’s Boggart take?
  • Next Week: It’s a MuggleMail bag covering Prisoner of Azkaban and the new Harry Potter TV show announcement
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by BetterHelp (visit BetterHelp.com/MuggleCast today to get 10% off your first month).
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we discuss more breaking news… a brand-new Quidditch video game! Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast!  As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now

Episode #607: Third Time’s The Charm (POA Chapter 5, The Dementor)

CHOO CHOO! On this week’s episode, we’re on the Hogwarts Express for what is sure to be another lovely… enchanting… peaceful… safe….. ride to Hogwarts. As they say, the third time’s the charm, and this year everything’s gonna be A-OK!

  • News covers the recently confirmed Harry Potter television series! Be sure to check out Episode 606, where we dive deep into the initial news leak and this week’s Bonus MuggleCast, where we discuss all the new details!
  • And… check out MuggleCast Episode 483, where we fan-casted a Harry Potter television show, and Episode 566, where the hosts developed ideas for an all-new Harry Potter television series!
  • Main Discussion: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 5: The Dementor
  • 7-Word Summary: Fear about the murderer abounds on trains
  • We contrast Harry’s trips to King’s Cross in Prisoner of Azkaban and Order of the Phoenix
  • How much information do we think Arthur would have offered to Harry about Sirius Black if Harry didn’t tell him he was already “in the know”?
  • Welcome, Remus Lupin! Check out the full Pottermore article on him and his family!
  • How did Dumbledore convince Lupin to take the post of Defense Against The Dark Arts?
  • Laura offers some interesting insight on the Wolfsbane Potion, lyncathropy and the AIDS epidemic of the 1990s
  • Why is Snape so angry with Lupin being named to the Defense Against The Dark Arts post?
  • We analyze the effect the Dementor had on Harry, Ginny and Neville
  • Could a Dementor have removed the Horcrux from Harry? What if it took Harry’s soul and left Voldemort’s?
  • Could anything have been done to prevent the Dementors from boarding the train? Did Dumbledore intentionally place Lupin on the train for this very reason?
  • With McGonagall tending to Harry and Hermione, just who the hell hosted the Sorting Ceremony?
  • Odds & Ends cover Sneakoscopes, Hogsmeade, the Shrieking Shack, secret passages, thestrals, forgetting passwords and more!
  • Quizzitch: Who guides the trio to their first Divination class?
  • Next Week: Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 6: Talons and Tea Leaves
  • This week’s episode is brought to you by Indeed (visit Indeed.com/MuggleCast to start hiring now) and MeUndies (get 25% off your first order, plus free standard shipping at MeUndies.com/MuggleCast).
  • And don’t forget! There’s much more MuggleCast waiting for you on Patreon, including Bonus MuggleCast segments! This week, we discuss breaking news… a brand-new Harry Potter TV show is coming to HBO!
  • Become a patron of ours today at Patreon.com/MuggleCast!  As always, we appreciate your support of the show!

Download now